发烧论坛

首页 » 发烧专区 » 音乐唱片 » 求同好相助--能推荐点梅纽因立体声的录音吗?
ZXW2216 - 2008/10/22 23:50:00
我的音乐取向比较奇怪,欣赏水平也不高,最喜欢的小提琴大师是梅纽因(在我心里排第一,米大爷第二,拉宾第三,海大爷第四,没大卫啥事),老头的好东西都是小时侯的,但是他立体声时期的东西听的不多,感觉有些浪费,因为"SOIL"可是把好琴呀,不听立体声可惜了.
有经验的DX给推荐点呗,我知道他技术衰退的厉害,但是不影响我喜欢他
我手头的老梅头立体声有:门德尔松\布鲁赫(我有天使版,几张里这个技术最惨);巴托克一小协、中提琴(录得象小提琴)狂想曲;帕格尼尼(平时只听两个第二乐章);贝多芬奏鸣曲(这个要上全套了).
哪位好心,再给咱说点录音好的,谢了

补充:LP就算了,搞不起;CD就中
垂钓 - 2008/10/22 23:55:00
                 EMI有梅老的贝小协,值得收藏:)
ZXW2216 - 2008/10/22 23:58:00
原帖由 垂钓 于 2008-10-22 23:55:00 发表
                 EMI有梅老的贝小协,值得收藏:)  


谢谢,我有俩单声,就没立体声。。。立体声长啥样?听过西尔维斯特里版,没封面
reverie - 2008/10/23 0:31:00
DG的那套Beethoven奏鸣曲,还有唯一录的一次Tchaikovsky协奏曲:+
mitropoulos - 2008/10/23 7:27:00
梅的早年仿佛天神下凡,又不染一丝矫揉造作的习气,大合大放,自然天成,让现今的种种所谓天才都一身大汗:Q
CJ御姐控 - 2008/10/23 8:03:00
几版巴托克第二小鞋都让我很失望:(
mitropoulos - 2008/10/23 8:28:00
参考版我也不喜欢 但是水星的演奏和录音都不错啊

113918
ACE - 2008/10/23 8:49:00
立体声录音里面,他的贝小奏是首选
ZXW2216 - 2008/10/23 10:21:00
原帖由 CJ御姐控 于 2008-10-23 8:03:00 发表
几版巴托克第二小鞋都让我很失望:(  


愿闻其祥:)
ZXW2216 - 2008/10/23 10:27:00
原帖由 mitropoulos 于 2008-10-23 8:28:00 发表
参考版我也不喜欢 但是水星的演奏和录音都不错啊

[attach]113918[/attach]


还好买吗?
ZXW2216 - 2008/10/23 10:36:00
原帖由 reverie 于 2008-10-23 0:31:00 发表
DG的那套Beethoven奏鸣曲,还有唯一录的一次Tchaikovsky协奏曲:+  


"唯一录的一次Tchaikovsky协奏曲",49年录的,单声,我有:)
DG奏鸣曲5,9听了8年了,全套准备了
ZXW2216 - 2008/10/23 10:42:00
各位,老头和李格合作过吗?
chopin - 2008/10/23 10:52:00
原帖由 ZXW2216 于 2008-10-22 23:58:00 发表
原帖由 垂钓 于 2008-10-22 23:55:00 发表
                 EMI有梅老的贝小协,值得收藏:)  


谢谢,我有俩单声,就没立体声。。。立体声长啥样?听过西尔维斯特里版,没封面


有这个廉价版。

113947
ZXW2216 - 2008/10/23 11:50:00
谢谢肖大侠
CJ御姐控 - 2008/10/23 12:20:00
原帖由 ZXW2216 于 2008-10-23 10:21:00 发表
原帖由 CJ御姐控 于 2008-10-23 8:03:00 发表
几版巴托克第二小鞋都让我很失望:(  


愿闻其祥:)


听过七八个版本之后的感想
ZXW2216 - 2008/10/23 12:40:00
大哥...您真是言简意赅...
换个问法:您对谁的版本比较满意...
这曲子我只听过一版,参考单声
tingpianer - 2008/10/23 13:17:00
113973

这个很好听,更适合入门者。且唱片罕见。
herrfisch - 2008/10/23 13:38:00
梅纽因立体声录音非常多,EMI专门出了一个环保装~
这个是HMV链接,李源那里肯定能订到,其中包含了绝大多数的梅纽因立体声协奏曲录音:
http://www.hmv.co.jp/product/detail/1951872
此外该系列还有一套Handel 专集里收入了梅纽因的亨德尔小提琴奏鸣曲全集~
另有一套Bach 专集收入了梅纽因的立体声版巴赫小提琴协奏曲~

本人曾经听过新版references参考系列中收入的梅纽因和Kentner 合作的巴赫小提琴奏鸣曲集,单声道录音,极其出色,可惜只有盗版,正版无处可寻~
herrfisch - 2008/10/23 13:40:00
上帖中梅纽因协奏曲录音集的曲目及合作者信息如下:
   Johann Sebastian Bach (1685 - 1750)  
Concerto for Violin no 1 in A minor, BWV 1041
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Menuhin, Yehudi
• Ensemble : Robert Masters Chamber Orchestra


Period: Baroque Style: Concerto Composed in: 1717-1723, Cothen, Germany
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Johann Sebastian Bach (1685 - 1750)  
Concerto for Violin no 2 in E major, BWV 1042
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Menuhin, Yehudi
• Ensemble : Robert Masters Chamber Orchestra


Period: Baroque Style: Concerto Composed in: 1717-1723, Cothen, Germany
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Johann Sebastian Bach (1685 - 1750)  
Brandenburg Concerto no 5 in D major, BWV 1050
• Performer : Malcolm, George (Harpsichord), Shaffer, Elaine (Flute)
• Conductor : Menuhin, Yehudi
• Ensemble : Bath Festival Orchestra


Period: Baroque Style: Concerto Composed in: 1720-1721, ?Cothen, Germany
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Bela Bartok (1881 - 1945)  
Concerto for Violin no 2, Sz 112
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Dorati, Antal
• Ensemble : New Philharmonia Orchestra


Period: 20th Century Style: Concerto Composed in: 1937-1938, Budapest, Hungary
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Bela Bartok (1881 - 1945)  
Rhapsody for Violin and Orchestra no 2, Sz 90
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Dorati, Antal
• Ensemble : New Philharmonia Orchestra


Period: 20th Century Style: Rhapsody Composed in: 1928, Budapest, Hungary
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Alban Berg (1885 - 1935)  
Concerto for Violin
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Boulez, Pierre
• Ensemble : BBC Symphony Orchestra


Period: 20th Century Style: Concerto Composed in: 1935, Austria
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Ludwig van Beethoven (1770 - 1827)  
Concerto for Violin in D major, Op. 61
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Menuhin, Yehudi
• Ensemble : Menuhin Festival Orchestra


Period: Classical Style: Concerto Composed in: 1806, Vienna, Austria
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Ludwig van Beethoven (1770 - 1827)  
Romance for Violin and Orchestra no 2 in F major, Op. 50
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Pritchard, John
• Ensemble : Philharmonia Orchestra


Period: Classical Style: Romance Composed in: ?1798, Vienna, Austria
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Max Bruch (1838 - 1920)  
Concerto for Violin no 1 in G minor, Op. 26
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Boult, Adrian, Sir
• Ensemble : London Symphony Orchestra


Period: Romantic Style: Concerto Composed in: 1868, Germany
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Johannes Brahms (1833 - 1897)  
Concerto for Violin in D major, Op. 77
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Kempe, Rudolf
• Ensemble : Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra


Period: Romantic Style: Concerto Composed in: 1878, Austria
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Felix Mendelssohn (1809 - 1847)  
Concerto for Violin in E minor, Op. 64
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Fruhbeck de Burgos, R.
• Ensemble : London Symphony Orchestra


Period: Romantic Style: Concerto Composed in: 1844, Germany
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Sir Edward Elgar (1857 - 1934)  
Concerto for Violin in B minor, Op. 61
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Boult, Adrian, Sir
• Ensemble : New Philharmonia Orchestra


Period: Romantic Style: Concerto Composed in: 1909-1910, England
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Sir William Walton (1902 - 1983)  
Concerto for Violin in B minor
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Walton, William, Sir
• Ensemble : London Symphony Orchestra


Period: 20th Century Style: Concerto Composed in: 1938-1939, England
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Franz Joseph Haydn (1732 - 1809)  
Concerto for Violin no 1 in C major, H 7a no 1
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Menuhin, Yehudi
• Ensemble : Bath Festival Orchestra


Period: Classical Style: Concerto Composed in: by 1769, Eszterhaza, Hungary
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756 - 1791)  
Concerto for Violin no 4 in D major, K 218
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Pritchard, John
• Ensemble : Philharmonia Orchestra


Period: Classical Style: Concerto Composed in: 1775, Salzburg, Austria
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart (1756 - 1791)  
Sinfonia concertante for Violin and Viola in E flat major, K 364 (320d)
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin), Barshai, Rudolf (Viola)
• Conductor : Menuhin, Yehudi
• Ensemble : Bath Festival Orchestra


Period: Classical Style: Concerto / Sinfonia Concertante Composed in: 1779, Salzburg, Austria
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Edouard Lalo (1823 - 1892)  
Symphonie espagnole, Op. 21
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Goossens, Eugene, Sir
• Ensemble : Philharmonia Orchestra


Period: Romantic Style: Concerto / Symphony Composed in: 1873, France
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Camille Saint-Saens (1835 - 1921)  
Concerto for Violin no 3 in B minor, Op. 61
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Poulet, Gaston
• Ensemble : London Symphony Orchestra


Period: Romantic Style: Concerto Composed in: 1880, France
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Camille Saint-Saens (1835 - 1921)  
Havanaise for Violin and Orchestra in E major, Op. 83
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Goossens, Eugene, Sir
• Ensemble : Philharmonia Orchestra


Period: Romantic Style:  Composed in: 1887, France
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Camille Saint-Saens (1835 - 1921)  
Introduction and Rondo capriccioso for Violin and Orchestra in A minor, Op. 28
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Goossens, Eugene, Sir
• Ensemble : Philharmonia Orchestra


Period: Romantic Style: Introduction / Rondo Composed in: 1863, France
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Niccolo Paganini (1782 - 1840)  
Concerto for Violin no 1 in D major, Op. 6
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Fistoulari, Anatole
• Ensemble : London Symphony Orchestra


Period: Romantic Style: Concerto Composed in: ?1817,  
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Henri Vieuxtemps (1820 - 1881)  
Concerto for Violin no 4 in D minor, Op. 31
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Susskind, Walter
• Ensemble : Philharmonia Orchestra


Period: Romantic Style: Concerto Composed in: circa 1850,  
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Henri Vieuxtemps (1820 - 1881)  
Concerto for Violin no 5 in A minor, Op. 37 "Gretry"
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Fistoulari, Anatole
• Ensemble : Philharmonia Orchestra


Period: Romantic Style: Concerto Composed in: 1861, Belgium
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Peter Ilyich Tchaikovsky (1840 - 1893)  
Serenade melancolique for Violin and Orchestra in B minor, Op. 26
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Boult, Adrian, Sir
• Ensemble : Royal Philharmonic Orchestra


Period: Romantic Style: Serenade Composed in: 1875, Russia
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Jean Sibelius (1865 - 1957)  
Concerto for Violin in D minor, Op. 47
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Boult, Adrian, Sir
• Ensemble : London Symphony Orchestra


Period: Romantic Style: Concerto Composed in: 1903-1905, Finland
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Carl Nielsen (Composer) (1865 - 1931)  
Concerto for Violin, Op. 33
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Woldike, Mogens
• Ensemble : Danish Radio Symphony Orchestra


Period: 20th Century Style: Concerto Composed in: 1911, Denmark
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Antonio Vivaldi (1678 - 1741)  
Concerto for Violin in E major, Op. 8 no 1/RV 269 "Primavera"
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin), Cocker, Paul (Harpsichord)
• Conductor : Lysy, Alberto
• Ensemble : Camerata Lysy


Period: Baroque Style: Concerto Composed in: circa 1725, Venice, Italy
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Antonio Vivaldi (1678 - 1741)  
Concerto for Violin in G minor, Op. 8 no 2/RV 315 "L'estate"
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin), Cocker, Paul (Harpsichord)
• Conductor : Lysy, Alberto
• Ensemble : Camerata Lysy


Period: Baroque Style: Concerto Composed in: 1725, Venice, Italy
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Antonio Vivaldi (1678 - 1741)  
Concerto for Violin in F major, Op. 8 no 3/RV 293 "L'autunno"
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin), Cocker, Paul (Harpsichord)
• Conductor : Lysy, Alberto
• Ensemble : Camerata Lysy


Period: Baroque Style: Concerto Composed in: 1725, Venice, Italy
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Antonio Vivaldi (1678 - 1741)  
Concerto for Violin in F minor, Op. 8 no 4/RV 297 "L'inverno"
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin), Cocker, Paul (Harpsichord)
• Conductor : Lysy, Alberto
• Ensemble : Camerata Lysy


Period: Baroque Style: Concerto Composed in: 1725, Venice, Italy
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Arcangelo Corelli (1653 - 1713)  
Concerti grossi (12), Op. 6: no 8 in G minor "Christmas"
• Performer : Simpson, Derek (Cello), Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin), Masters, Robert (Violin)
• Conductor : Tippett, Michael
• Ensemble : Bath Festival Orchestra


Period: Baroque Style: Concerto Grosso Composed in: 1708-1712, Rome, Italy
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Michael Tippett (1905 - 1998)  
Fantasia concertante on a theme of Corelli
• Performer : Simpson, Derek (Cello), Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin), Masters, Robert (Violin)
• Conductor : Tippett, Michael
• Ensemble : Bath Festival Orchestra


Period: 20th Century Style: Fantasy / Concerto Composed in: 1953, England
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Johann Sebastian Bach (1685 - 1750)  
Concerto for 2 Violins in D minor, BWV 1043
• Performer : Vito, Gioconda de (Violin)
• Conductor : Bernard, Anthony
• Ensemble : Philharmonia Orchestra


Period: Baroque Style: Concerto Composed in: 1717-1723, Cothen, Germany
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Ludwig van Beethoven (1770 - 1827)  
Romance for Violin and Orchestra no 1 in G major, Op. 40
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin)
• Conductor : Menuhin, Yehudi
• Ensemble : Menuhin Festival Orchestra


Period: Classical Style: Romance Composed in: 1802, Vienna, Austria
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]  

  

   Antonio Vivaldi (1678 - 1741)  
Concertos (4) for Violin, Op. 8 no 1-4 "Four seasons"
• Performer : Menuhin, Yehudi (Violin), Cocker, Paul (Harpsichord)
• Conductor : Lysy, Alberto
• Ensemble : Camerata Lysy


Period: Baroque Style: Concerto Composed in: circa 1725, Venice, Italy
Language:  Time: : Recorded on: , [Studio]
垂钓 - 2008/10/23 14:10:00
                 我的那张曲目和你这张一样的,但是是中价板好像,忘记价钱了:Z :Z :Z :Z
xiaocao - 2008/10/23 18:59:00
印象里有一张和古尔德合作的sonycbs
买过盗版
里面有一首巴赫的小提琴奏鸣曲
贝多芬第十奏鸣曲
和勋伯格的一个什么作品
其中第一首巴赫的作品异常好听(至少比大键琴伴奏的好听)
强烈推荐^_^
beijingyulu - 2008/10/23 19:03:00
他和老克的贝多芬还是满不错的~貌似是立体声的~?:D
关山月_ - 2008/10/23 19:36:00
原帖由 herrfisch 于 2008-10-23 13:38:00 发表
本人曾经听过新版references参考系列中收入的梅纽因和Kentner 合作的巴赫小提琴奏鸣曲集,单声道录音,极其出色,可惜只有盗版,正版无处可寻~


这个我会帮你留意!
海森堡的幽灵 - 2008/10/23 21:28:00
114053

立体声版的贝小协就是这张。但是坦率地说,我最喜爱的指挥家和小提琴家的合作并不能完全令我满意呀。克伦佩勒的乐队协奏虽然速度慢,但很节奏干净,紧凑,并不拖沓, 梅纽因的技术已经退步,因此也是选择拉得慢而细致,可是两个人都慢,协奏演出就缺乏高潮,稍嫌拖沓。
akennadun - 2008/10/23 23:02:00
梅纽因在EMI的立体声录音中,个人首荐的是这个:
114083
ZXW2216 - 2008/10/24 9:22:00
一眼没照顾到,大家给推荐了这么多...都感谢不过来了
谢谢各位,谢谢:)
天道酬勤;碟到筹钱
先记下这些,各位,多来点封面吧,正好坛子里关于梅纽因立体声的东西不太多,顺便给如我之需的朋友们也搭个台,相关的东西来这找就行了,谢谢各位:D
ZXW2216 - 2008/10/24 9:26:00
原帖由 海森堡的幽灵 于 2008-10-23 21:28:00 发表


立体声版的贝小协就是这张。但是坦率地说,我最喜爱的指挥家和小提琴家的合作并不能完全令我满意呀。克伦佩勒的乐队协奏虽然速度慢,但很节奏干净,紧凑,并不拖沓, 梅纽因的技术已经退步,因此也是选择拉得慢而细致,可是两个人都慢,协奏演出就缺乏高潮,稍嫌拖沓。



对这个拖沓很好奇:D
ZXW2216 - 2008/10/24 9:41:00
原帖由 herrfisch 于 2008-10-23 13:38:00 发表
梅纽因立体声录音非常多,EMI专门出了一个环保装~
这个是HMV链接,李源那里肯定能订到,其中包含了绝大多数的梅纽因立体声协奏曲录音:
http://www.hmv.co.jp/product/detail/1951872
此外该系列还有一套Handel 专集里收入了梅纽因的亨德尔小提琴奏鸣曲全集~
另有一套Bach 专集收入了梅纽因的立体声版巴赫小提琴协奏曲~



辛苦您了,这份资料太全了,谢谢
海森堡的幽灵 - 2008/10/24 12:45:00
呵呵,其实很像他和肯普夫合作的贝小奏的感觉吧,细致,线条优美,但是不是太慢了点?当然,等我再老几岁说不定审美观点也会变化的。:Z
64643432 - 2008/11/3 10:27:00
他的鼎盛時期應該在40年代吧




b
12
查看完整版本: 求同好相助--能推荐点梅纽因立体声的录音吗?