今天无意中看到一个rec.music.classical.recordings的讨论，主题是 Most awful piano concerto。 其中有人提到"Yellow River" Concerto。我来把其中对"Yellow River" Concerto的评价摘出来。
"Matthew B. Tepper" <
oyt@earthlink.net>：
Some Committee or Other, "Yellow River" Concerto. The RCA version of this
with Daniel Epstein is NOT among the Ormandy/Philadelphia Orchestra
recordings that I'd most like to see reissued.
"yenda smejkal" <
yenda.smej...@ntlworld.com>：
。。。i think the yellow river concerto is a gorgeous piece and i listen to it
often.
"Russ and/or Martha Oppenheim" <
moppenh...@satx.rr.com>:
The Yellow River, of which I caught a bit by accident
on FM, is truly vile.
Andy Evans <
performanceandme...@gmail.com>:
We have to be thinking "worse than the Warsaw Concerto" so something
like The Yellow River Piano Concerto of which Takemitsu said ""How
could a nation as great as China come up with such a composition!"
sechumlib <
sechum...@liberal.net>:
("How could a nation as great as China come up with such a composition!") If the whole nation, or even a committee thereof, is listed as the
"composer", I can see that as a possibility. And that WAS the situation
with regard to that "work".
schu...@mail.biu.ack.il (Richard Schultz):
In article <462dfbaa$0$19375$
4c368...@roadrunner.com>, sechumlib <
sechum...@liberal.net> wrote:
: Well, there's always the Grieg - if you're looking for something to fit
: your title.
I take it that you've never heard the "Yellow River" Concerto.
简单地说，以上几人除yenda smejkal外都是恶评。有兴趣的，可以去看原贴：
http://groups.google.com/group/rec.music.classical.recordings/browse_thread/thread/43d724ad59191b0e/573913a53d6446c9?hl=en&