罗斯托和富尼埃的BACH无伴奏大提琴，谁好？ [复制链接]

ymm 在 2003-5-3 2:19:48 发表的内容 你们还是听听Winter and winter唱片，由Paolo beschi演奏的巴赫无伴奏吧，那才是第一流的录音！！！！

大佬，320米！下次弄它一套。

李源 在 2003-5-2 23:20:58 发表的内容 9494

李源兄，你那里有没有罗斯特罗波维奇的巴赫大无伴奏，上次问了很久怎么都没有答复呀？

fournier日版，第一选择。

无第一只有自己手里那杯茶

当年我听了第一遍卡萨尔斯的巴赫大无后，就把罗的那套emi的送给旁边的哥们了。

拿完整录音来说，罗斯特2套，富尼埃4套，不要说是两个人之间比，就算自己跟自己比都是很难有结论的事情。如果是为了“听”，怎么买就只有两个原则：哪个听着顺耳，以及差不差钱。

我先从天津刘兄那搞了卡萨尔斯的，很喜欢。后来买了老罗的，呵呵，更喜欢了。后来一直没有再听卡萨尔斯，我承认和录音是有关系的。富尼埃的没听过。

比较版本很无聊，每个人心里都有一个甚至几个哈姆雷特，没有谁好谁坏或哪个最好一说。现今手里有40多个版本的巴赫大无，没觉得楼上说的那些版本有多么神。多听听其他人的演绎，就会发现他们各有所长，各有对作品的不同理解和诠释。就我个人的口味而言，比较喜欢Antonio Janigro, Erich Mainardi, Pierre Fournier, Andre Navarra, Janos Starker, Wieland Kuijken, Marc Coppey 等人的演绎。即将出版的老罗的一个巴赫大无全集，55年版，才28岁，应该叫小罗。

From www.supraphon.com，
Johann Sebastian Bach – Six Suites for Solo Cello, BWV 1007-1012  
(LIVE recording from Prague Spring 1955)
Mstislav Rostropovich – cello
Today, Bach's suites form part of the repertoire of every distinguished cellist, and many of them have recorded the complete cycle. Yet when sixty years ago the twenty-four-year-old Mstislav Rostropovich (1927–2007) first performed all the suites in public, it was a trailblazing act, linking up to the previous endeavour of Pablo Casals. When this live recording was made in 1955 at the Prague Spring festival, Rostropovich was 28 years of age. He astounded the audience with his youthful verve and surprising artistic maturity. At the festival Rostropovich met his lifelong love, Galina Vishnevskaya, whom upon returning to Moscow he married after several days of acquaintance. When in 1991 the cellist made a complete recording of the Bach suites in France, he was 64. Hence, all the more precious is this live recording from the Czech Radio archives, which waited more than half a century for its release.
As a lover and connoisseur of wine, Rostropovich would certainly agree that some wines – and some recordings too – acquire a richer taste and a higher value over time.

晕，ls好无聊，这里就是论坛，版本比较只是说自己的看法，难道说说自己对唱片的看法就很俗？既然觉得俗，觉得无聊你还来干什么呀？