请与
Patzak前辈2002 年时在<爱乐人,走四方>上的帖子对照: (转贴,谢Patzak前辈) 找到一個尚算齊全的 Complete Recordings of Beethoven's 32 Piano Sonatas 目錄, 供眾樂友參考. 它主要是以單一位鋼琴家的錄音來計算, 並按英文姓氏來排列的.
1/. Arrau, Claudio / Philips (11 CD set). 1967, 13 LP set was Philips 6747035 1960's
2/. Ashkenazy, Vladimir / Decca (10 CD set: 2LC10 443-706). Includes Andante Favori 1970's - 1980's 10h, 41m
3/. Backhaus, Wilhelm / Decca (8 CD set). 1970, 10 LP set was: London CSP 2 (CS 6683-6692) 1958-69. 1953 (op.106)
4/. Badura-Skoda, Paul / Musical Heritage Society OR B 375-385 (11 LPs) 1970
5/. Barenboim, Daniel / EMI (10 CD set).1970, 14 LP set: Angel SNLV 3755 1965-69 11h, 27m
6/. Barenboim, Daniel / DG (9 CD set reissue).Originally 12 LPs, then 12 CDs 1980's 11h, 07m
7/. Binns, Malcolm (fortepianos) / L'Oiseau Lyre (LPs only) 1980
8/. Brendel, Alfred / Vox-Turnabout (LPs reissued on CDs) 1958-64
9/. Brendel, Alfred / Philips (11 CD set).Originally 13 LPs. Includes Andante Favori 1978
10/. Brendel, Alfred / Philips (10 CD set) 1992-6 10h, 58m
11/. Buchbinder, Rudolf / Teldec (8 CD set) 1980's
12/. Fischer, Annie / Hungaraton (CD) 1970's
13/. Frank, Claude / Music & Arts MUA 640 (CD reissue). Orig. 12 LP set: RCA Victrola VICS 9000 1970
14/. Goode, Richard / Nonesuch (10 CD set) 1980's 10h, 12m
15/. Gulda, Friedrich / Decca LPs 1950's
16/. Gulda, Friedrich / Philips (9 CD set). 11 LP set was Amadeo & Orpheus labels (OR B 116-126) 1967
17/. Heidsieck, Eric / EMI Classics (4 83427 2) 1970's?
18/. Hobson, Ian / Zephyr (9 CD set) 1992-6 10h, 30m
19/. Houstoun, Michael / Morrison Music Trust, New Zealand (
www.trustcd.com) 1995-7
20/. Hungerford, Bruce / Vanguard 1968-74
21/. Jando, Jeno / Naxos (10 CDs) 1980's
22/. Kempff, Wilhelm / DG 1930's (mono)
23/. Kempff, Wilhelm / DG (8 CD set) 1951-2 (mono)
24/. Kempff, Wilhelm / DG (8 CD set*, also a 9 CD set**). Orig. 10 LP set (1964): KL 42-51 1962-4 9h, 54m*; 9h 57m**
25/. Kuerti, Anton / Odyssey (Orig. 13 LP set: Y 34646-34649, Rec. by Aquitaine Records) 1976
26/. Kuerti, Anton / Analekta-Fleur De Lys 24010 (CD) 1995
27/. Lill, John / ASV Quicksilva (CDs) 1970's
28/. Nat, Yves / EMI (8 CD set) 1954-5 (mono)
29/. Nikoleyeva, Tatiana / Olympia (UK) (CDs) 1980's
30/. O'Conor, Jon / Telarc (9 CD set) 1980's
31/. Perl, Alfredo / Arte Nova (10 CD set) 1990's 11h, 46m
32/. Pommier, Jean-Bernard / Erato 1990's
33/. Rangell, Andrew / Dorian (CDs) 1990's
34/. Roberts, Bernard / Nimbus (9 CD set) 1980's 10h, 45m
35/. Schnabel, Artur / EMI (8 CDs).Also on Pearl, Arkadia (8 CDs) 1932-7 (mono)
36/. Sherman, Rusell / Gm Recordings - #5001 (CDs) 1993-7 10h, 52m
37/. Silverman, Robert / Orpheum Masters KSP830 (10 CD set). B?sendorfer Reproducing Piano 2000
38/. Steinberg, Michael / Elysium
39/. Taub, Robert / Vox (CDs) 1990's
40/. Willems, Gerard / ABC (9 CD set) (
http://www.beethoven-sonatas.com/) 1997-2000
整整四十個不同時代的錄音, 洋洋大觀也! : )
另Emil Gilels 在DGG 的Beethoven Piano Sonatas 錄音, 的確不全, 看下列資料附記之(三) , 便知其詳矣.
(一) Gieseking, Walter / EMI. Completed two-thirds of a cycle before his death in 1956.
(二) Gieseking, Walter / Tahra. Missing sonatas 4, 5, 7, 20, 22. These are from 1949 broadcasts. He recorded all 32, but tapes of some are lost.
(三) Gilels, Emil / DG. Missing nos. 1, 9, 22, 24, 32. Died before completing cycle.
(四) Gould, Glenn / SONY. Missing nos. 4, 11, 19-22, 25-28
(五) Kovacevich, Stephen / Cycle in progress on EMI
(六) Pollini, Maurizio / DGG Recorded nos. 11-15, 17, 21, 25-32. DGG is considering having Pollini complete the cycle (according to a DG internet chat).
(七) Serkin, Rudolf / SONY. Recorded nos. 1, 6, 8, 12-14, 16, 21, 23, 26, 30-32. Also recorded 30-32 on DG
(八) Solomon (1952-6) / EMI (Testament reissues). Recorded nos.1,3,7,8,13,14,32,17,18,21,22,26-32. Suffered a stroke in 1956 before he could complete the cycle.
而其中 28/. 法國鋼琴家 Yves Nat ( 1890-1954 ) 的 8 CDs 合集, 編號為 CZS 7 62901 2 , 當日是特廉的售價, 而Artur Schnabel 的, 卻是中價. 我因為覺得已擁有了後者的劃時代之演繹, 所以就沒買下Yves Nat 這套CDs 了.
但事實上, 我又好想听听Yves Nat 的演繹, 所以便買了一張他彈奏"Appassionata" , "Pathetique" 及 "Moonlight" 的 EMI References CDH 5 61012 2 單張 CD 了.
印象並不太深: 觸鍵輕盈, 做句一般, 歌唱性不足, 与 Walter Gieseking 同一曲目, 同一唱片公司 ( EMI ) 的出品, 有天壤雲泥之別!
當然, 這是我多年前之感受, 況且又是極個人之看法而已. 能夠有機會多听听不同風格的演繹, 恐怕才是人生的一大樂事! : )
